Your Cart ()
cload

GUARANTEED SAFE & SECURE CHECKOUT

🚚 ALWAYS FREE SHIPPING TO USA 🇺🇸 on System Purchases (excludes AK, HI, & PR)
SIZE YOUR WATER SOFTENER CALL NOW
Need Help? Speak to an Expert!
Phone Icon855-683-8488
Mon-Fri 9am-7pm CST

The Charcoal Myth: Does A Charcoal Filter Remove Fluoride? Why SoftPro Uses Bone Char Instead

The Charcoal Myth: Does A Charcoal Filter Remove Fluoride? Why SoftPro Uses Bone Char Instead

Written by Craig "The Water Guy" Phillips

Understanding Charcoal Filtration

Charcoal, or as science-y folks call it, activated carbon, is a well-loved choice in water filters. Let's check out how these filters pull their magic trick and where they slip up, especially when it comes to booting out fluoride.

How Activated Carbon Filters Work

Activated carbon filters do their thing through adsorption, which is just a fancy way of saying, "Stick this here." When H2O rushes through, nasty stuff like chlorine, grime, and those sneaky volatile organic bits get stuck to the charcoal's all-over-the-place surface. Think of it as the charcoal having plenty of sticky fingers reaching out to grab the bad guys. This property makes them all-star performers when it comes to scrubbing up funny tastes and smells from water. This is why you find these bad boys in homes and businesses everywhere, doing their bit to keep water clean.

Contaminant Effectiveness
Chlorine High
Sediment High
Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) High
Fluoride Low

Limitations of Charcoal Filters

While activated carbon filters make these wonky tastes and smells hit the road, they're not perfect. Their kryptonite? Fluoride. Those tiny fluoride ions are like invisible ninjas, slipping right through without getting caught. This can be a bummer if you're a family worried about fluoride swimming around your drinking water, like the Parker family who are on the lookout for a better solution to kick fluoride to the curb.

Contaminant Effectiveness
Fluoride Low
Nitrate Low
Sodium Low
Minerals Low

So, what do you do if you want to kick fluoride out of your water party? Consider hitting up fluoride-specialized filters, reverse osmosis systems, or deionizers. If you’re after ways to shoo fluoride away, check out our piece on what water filter removes fluoride for more insights and get those smarty pants decisions in line with your water needs.

Fluoride Removal Methods

Reverse Osmosis Systems

Reverse osmosis (RO) systems are champs at kicking fluoride out of your water. They pull out all sorts of baddies—fluoride, hexavalent chromium, arsenic, you name it—by forcing water through a fancy membrane. Keep in mind, they can be a bit thirsty and use more water during their magic.

Contaminant How Much They Get Rid Of
Fluoride 90-95%
Hexavalent Chromium 90-95%
Arsenic 90-95%
Nitrates/Nitrites 90-95%
Copper 90-95%
Radium 90-95%
Salt 90-95%

Deionizers for Fluoride Removal

Deionizers, or ion exchange filters, are another way to show fluoride the door. They swap out mineral ions with the bad stuff, making them pretty handy for home use. They might not be as straightforward as RO systems, and they do demand a bit more care (Ace Water Shop).

Pros Cons
Great at getting rid of fluoride Needs regular TLC
Fits well in homes Can be a bit finicky

Fluoride-Specific Filters

Want something specifically for fluoride? Some filter systems, like the ones using bone char or activated alumina, are designed just for that. Perfect for when you want to tackle fluoride with precision (Ace Water Shop). This know-how can help keep your water fluoride-free and tasty.

Filter Type Fluoride Removal Rate
Bone Char 90-95%
Activated Alumina 90-95%

For more tips on keeping your water pristine, check out our detailed guides on removing fluoride from your water and picking the best water filter that targets fluoride and chlorine. Safe sipping!

Effectiveness of Charcoal Filters

We all want clean, tasty water, right? Charcoal filters, or as some call them, activated carbon filters, are a big hit in the water-filter world. But here's the kicker: they might not be great with everything—like kicking fluoride to the curb. Let's see what these guys can grab and what slips through the cracks.

Contaminants Trapped by Charcoal Filters

Charcoal filters are like the superheroes of water purification—great at scooping up the bad stuff. Here’s what they shine at boxing out:

  • Chlorine: They take out up to 99% of chlorine, making your water taste and smell way better.
  • Sediment: Big chunks of dirt and sand? Consider them caught.
  • Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs): Those stubborn harmful chemicals don't stand a chance against the activated carbon's porous defenses.
  • Organic Chemicals: It battles against pesticides, herbicides, and more with might.

Check out this little cheat sheet showing what charcoal filters can do:

Contaminant Reduction Level
Chlorine 95-99%
Sediment 90-99%
VOCs 95-99%
Organic Chemicals 85-95%

Fluoride Adsorption by Activated Carbon

Here’s where our hero falters a bit. Fluoride is one slippery character—tiny and rockin' a negative charge. Because of this, the usual charcoal filter can't keep up. So, if getting rid of fluoride is your game plan, you'll need to look elsewhere. We're talking reverse osmosis, deionizers, or specialized filters that mean business.

Need more info on getting fluoride out? Check out our resources for removing fluoride from water. For a double whammy—you've gotta hear about our [SoftPro Whole House Fluoride & Carbon Filter]. This baby tackles everything fluoride and the rest of the nasties, too. Get the skinny on filters that remove fluoride and chlorine.

In short, charcoal filters are champs at filtering tons of stuff but choke on fluoride. It's super important to know this if picking the right filter matters to you and it does if you like good water. Look at your options in our write-ups like what water filter removes fluoride and best water filter to remove fluoride. Happy filtering!

Alternative Fluoride Removal Solutions

Trying to figure out the best way to remove fluoride from water at home? Look no further. We’ve got a few tried-and-true methods up our sleeves, each with its own perks to boost your water quality.

Specialized Filtration Systems

What’s Your Water Score?


When it comes to fluoride removal, some filtration systems are like the superheroes of water purification. They're designed to tackle the fluoride problem head-on.

Filtration System Fluoride Removal Ability What Stands Out
Bone Char Filters Nearly 100% Uses bone char’s special powers to attract fluoride ions, thanks to its positive vibes (surface charge 4.5 mV) (PubMed Central)
Reverse Osmosis Systems 90-95% Kicks out fluoride with a semi-permeable membrane
Deionizers Varies Trades out fluoride ions for harmless ones like hydroxide or chloride

Bone Char Filters are fan favorites. Why? They use hydroxyapatite, which loves snatching up fluoride ions (PubMed Central). Great for those wanting to filter fluoride out of tap water.

Reverse Osmosis Systems work like a charm by pushing water through a filter that acts like a picky bouncer, showing fluoride the exit. They keep your water auditioning for the clean team but do need regular TLC to keep performing.

Combined Filtration Methods

Mixing and matching different filtration techniques? Now that’s where magic happens for fluoride filtration. The more, the merrier.

Combined Method How It Works Perks
GAC and Bone Char Combo Nearly 100% Maximizes GAC’s big surface area (739 m²/g) and bone char’s fluoride-loving charge
Activated Alumina and Carbon Filters 85-95% Activated alumina tackles fluoride while carbon takes care of the rest
RO with Pre-Filters 90-95% Pre-filters handle big stuff, prolonging the RO membrane’s life

A tag-team of Granulated Activated Carbon (GAC) and Bone Char showed super impressive numbers in tests, batting down fluoride for the long haul (NCBI). If you’re keen to ditch fluoride from water, this is your dynamic duo.

Activated Alumina and Carbon Filters take the fight to fluoride. Alumina does the time-consuming bit, and carbon swoops in to tidy up additional impurities like chlorine. A one-two punch for a cleaner sip.

By checking out these filtration superheroes and their sidekicks, we can make sure our homes get nothing but the best water. Whether you go for bone char, reverse osmosis, or a combo move, knowing the top tech for fluoride evictions is the way to go. Dive deeper into options with our guides on filters that remove fluoride and fluoride water filtration systems.

Making Informed Water Treatment Choices

Let's break down how to pick out a good water treatment setup for your home sweet home. It's really about knowing what you're dealing with before making a choice. We'll look at a range of filtration systems and help you suss out which one might have your back when it comes to getting clean, tasty drinking water.

Comparing Filtration Technologies

Deciphering the ins and outs of these filtration systems might seem a bit like assembling furniture with no manual, but hang tight! Here’s the lowdown on some favorites:

Filtration Type What It Kicks Out Positives Watch Out For
Activated Carbon Filters Chlorine, pesticides, VOCs Spruces up taste and smell, good on the wallet Not for fluoride, sodium, germs Water Professionals
Reverse Osmosis Systems Almost all nasties, including fluoride Super effective, does it all Pricey up front, needs upkeep Ace Water Shop
Activated Alumina Filters Fluoride, arsenic, selenium Cheap and cheerfully handles fluoride Needs changing often Ace Water Shop
Bone Char Carbon Filters Fluoride, heavy metals Earth-friendly, does the job well Costs a bit more than regular carbon NCBI

Safe and Effective Drinking Water Solutions

Got yourself a thirst for something refreshing and clean? Look into these filtration ideas:

  1. SoftPro Whole House Fluoride & Carbon Filter: This bad boy is all set to cut down fluoride and chlorine. It's tailored for folks drawing water from the city supply. Mixes in a combo of filtering techniques to fend off multiple nasties. Check out more on this setup by clicking here.

  2. SoftPro Whole House Catalytic Carbon Filter: Aims at reducing the usual chemicals including chlorine and VOCs. Great tasting water for homes using city or well water. Details await your perusal at fluoride filtration whole house.

  3. Combined Filtration Systems: For a supercharged duo, think about connecting a reverse osmosis system with an activated carbon filter. It’s like pairing peanut butter and jelly—awesome taste and complete purification. Peek into our detailed guide online at best water filter to remove fluoride.

  4. Professional Installation and Maintenance: Get your filtration system installed by pros. This ensures the whole shebang performs like a dream and gives you peace of mind about water quality. Check the details at fluoride water filtration.

Suss out these options and you'll be all set to cheer on your new water filtration pick. Dig deeper into our articles for juicy tidbits, side-by-side looks, and what others are saying. Go ahead, your sparkling water awaits!

Craig

Craig "The Water Guy" Phillips

Learn More

Craig "The Water Guy" Phillips is the founder of Quality Water Treatment (QWT) and creator of SoftPro Water Systems. 

With over 30 years of experience, Craig has transformed the water treatment industry through his commitment to honest solutions, innovative technology, and customer education.

Known for rejecting high-pressure sales tactics in favor of a consultative approach, Craig leads a family-owned business that serves thousands of households nationwide. 

Craig continues to drive innovation in water treatment while maintaining his mission of "transforming water for the betterment of humanity" through transparent pricing, comprehensive customer support, and genuine expertise. 

When not developing new water treatment solutions, Craig creates educational content to help homeowners make informed decisions about their water quality.